Debunking A Flat Earth Claim I Saw Years Ago
Many years ago when I was a wee undergraduate, out of morbid curiousity I decided to read the Flat Earth Society wiki. Here I learned of the concept of “universal acceleration” in which the Earth accelerates constantly at 9.8 meters per second, and this is what causes gravity.
With a modern understand of non-interial frames, universal acceleration does meaningfully explain the phenomenon of gravity, but the theory is still problematic because the Earth would eventually reach the speed of light if it were constantly accelerating, and our current understanding of physics forbids any object from exceeding the speed of light. However, to my surprise, the article for universal acceleration does some physics to account for this!
It is, of course, useless to debunk flat earth theories. However, I love an excuse to do some mathematics. So let’s do some math!
Let us derive the “Differential Equation for velocity on earth”
Believe it or not, this equation is physically sound. The result comes from Newton’s second law which we will write in the form
It so happens this form generalizes to special relativity
where the momentum is written as
,
where
is the
so-called Lorentz factor:
Let’s do some calculus on Newton’s second law to reduce it to a form we can use.
or, dividing both sides by ,
With some repeated use of the chain rule we have
(For academic honesty I should mention I consulted Wikipedia for help in this derivation.)
At this point you can see where the “Differential Equation
for velocity on earth” comes from. In a constant gravitational
field we have
Let’s separate variables and integrate. Assuming we start at rest then we have
Here, the trigonometric substitution saves us. Recalling that
and
we have
There is an identity here that we can derive by drawing a devilishly clever triangle:
And so we have
and squaring both sides and rearranging,
and so
You will notice this disagrees with the flat
earth result by a sign. This is because the writer
(intentionally?) added a minus sign when computing instead of a plus sign!
If we set to
and solve for
, we find that a
solution exists when
, which is about twenty-one and a half
million seconds, or less than a year. This means that, even
accounting for relativistic effects, the Earth would have long
reached the speed of light by now if it experienced universal
acceleration.
With the flat earther relativistic justification for universal acceleration debunked, I will leave you with two exercises:
- Find out how long it will take for a univerally-accelerating Earth to reach the speed of light when you ignore special relativity. How does this time compare to the relativistic result?
- Show that the velocity of a universally-accelerating Earth can become arbitrarily large.